Chief, that left photo you're referring to is identical of what I used the alien pic I posted with all the criticism, it's just the 240hz segment snipped and compared to another 240hz panel. If you can confirm that's what your panel looks like, I think it's safe to say they are all flawed.Chief Blur Buster wrote:Not all 240Hz monitors has this issue.Notty_PT wrote:If you look at the overdrive settings, this is exactly what my monitor looks like at 60hz and I think I've discovered the flaw of all these 240hz monitors. If you see 60 and 144 have a serious double image effect like you are drunk and I would bet all 240hz have this issue.
The very same site, TFTCentral confirms this:
See? Both 240Hz.
But in the left image
-- You can identify the black lines in the UFO better
-- The alien's eyes are much more distinct.
-- The UFO landing legs are much clearer.
-- The UFO's steering stick is much clearer.
The best 240Hz monitor has much clearer motion than the worst 240Hz.
The left image is what I see at 240 Hz.
The ViewSonic XG2530 and Acer XB252Q (at least the BlurBusters samples) looks closer to like the one at the left, and is significantly clearer than all my 144Hz monitors (including my BenQ's, Asus's, etc).
That said, I am VERY interested to understand *why* the inconsistency is appearing. We might be seeing a panel lottery issue, that needs larger amount of 240Hz purchases to verify.
Also another (unconfirmed) anecdote -- one reader posted several weeks ago they returned their 240Hz and got a replacement 240Hz monitor (of the same brand) that was apparently much better looking. This will need to be corroborated with more additional user reports.
Can you see all the flaws I listed in my previous post? Compare the 240hz mode to the 200hz mode in the photo above I posted. Also, the 240hz on the right of your photo is the AOC that had awful overdrive on launch, so I don't think it's fair to compare. I read they improved it in the G-Sync model?
If you think it's a panel inconsistency, I can try and exchange to help track down the issue. I do not mind, but it will probably take a week or so, as it won't be local, but a shipment. What brand is the one where the user exchanged and was much better?
Thanks for replying.
To be fair, you said some pretty dumb things in that thread, at least from what I read on the last page.Notty_PT wrote:
My friend I did notice this and other problems with these 240hz monitors. But I was completly bashed and attacked on most forums because of it so I gave up. You can see some of it on this link, be sure to grab some popcorn, look at my arguments against those guys that can´t accept they paid 500€ for a product that isn´t that great: http://www.overclock.net/t/1608085/asus ... t_26514185