Correct & confirmed: That screenshot are NOT inversion artifacts.
Inversion artifacts are impossible to screenshot; they must be photographed.
It might be the temporal dithering behaviour (the GPU version) or some other behaviour that was made visible to the screenshot process.
Things that make colors "noisy" includes things like:
- Lack of bit depth; and/or
- Inversion artifacts; and/or
- Banding artifacts; and/or
- Dither artifacts (by GPU, or by monitor FRC); and/or
- Software GPU shaders (intentional or unintentional); and/or
- Etc.
Some of these are screenshottable and some are definitely not.
Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2546?
- Chief Blur Buster
- Site Admin
- Posts: 11653
- Joined: 05 Dec 2013, 15:44
- Location: Toronto / Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
- Contact:
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
Head of Blur Busters - BlurBusters.com | TestUFO.com | Follow @BlurBusters on Twitter
Forum Rules wrote: 1. Rule #1: Be Nice. This is published forum rule #1. Even To Newbies & People You Disagree With!
2. Please report rule violations If you see a post that violates forum rules, then report the post.
3. ALWAYS respect indie testers here. See how indies are bootstrapping Blur Busters research!
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
It's just the optimization of the game. They have to dial down the accuracy of the shaders. How else are you going to get these high-FPS competitive games running at 200FPS or more while having them not look like a PS2 game from 2001.
Steam • GitHub • Stack Overflow
The views and opinions expressed in my posts are my own and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Blur Busters.
The views and opinions expressed in my posts are my own and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Blur Busters.
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 16 Jun 2019, 14:33
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
Chief, do you recommend me to return the monitor? or maybe the xl zowies tend to have pixel inversion? The truth is that it is not a very exaggerated pixel inversionChief Blur Buster wrote:Correct & confirmed: That screenshot are NOT inversion artifacts.
Inversion artifacts are impossible to screenshot; they must be photographed.
It might be the temporal dithering behaviour (the GPU version) or some other behaviour that was made visible to the screenshot process.
Things that make colors "noisy" includes things like:
- Lack of bit depth; and/or
- Inversion artifacts; and/or
- Banding artifacts; and/or
- Dither artifacts (by GPU, or by monitor FRC); and/or
- Software GPU shaders (intentional or unintentional); and/or
- Etc.
Some of these are screenshottable and some are definitely not.
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 16 Jun 2019, 14:33
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
someone has a zowie xl 2546? and if so ... do you have some pixel inversion artifact?
-
- Posts: 2795
- Joined: 26 Mar 2014, 07:23
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
"Apparently" the XL2740 is a true 8 bit panel.open wrote:There are multiple kinds of inversion patterns that can happen on a monitor. The first is voltage inversion done to protect the monitor from damage that may occur if a steady voltage is supplied. Instead positive voltage is used then negative in a cycle. The cycle uses an inversion pattern so that any visible effects are ditthered. This kind of inversion is most common and ideally will not be noticeable in daily use.
The second kind is typically more noticeable and more associated with modern 240hz monitors. It is the inversion pattern used for FRC. The monitor accpets an 8-bit signal but uses a 6-bit panel. To produce the last 2 bits of contrast the panel is alternated between ligher and darker shades over time. This alternation uses an inversion pattern to mask the puslsing. Fast eyes can catch it but more importantly it can be linked to refresh rate. So some situations particularly with gsync dropping to very low refreshes can make the inversion pattern very visible. Also the right kind of animations can show it. If something is already pulsing every other frame on part of the screen then it will catch half of the inversion pattern. There were some issues with earlier versions of windows 10 and earlier nvidia drivers that resulted in pulsing screens with inversion patterns in many games when the framerate dropped.
Im not sure if there are 8-bit 240hz panels in monitors yet. If there are maybe someone can chime in and that may be a good monitor for you to try.
But I can find no other source other than this
https://www.displayspecifications.com/en/model/aeb21048
They can't be just blatantly wrong because they label the XL2540 and XL2546 as both 6 bits+FRC.
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 16 Jun 2019, 14:33
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
because to be true of 8bits should not present inversion of pixels or that has nothing to do?Falkentyne wrote:"Apparently" the XL2740 is a true 8 bit panel.open wrote:There are multiple kinds of inversion patterns that can happen on a monitor. The first is voltage inversion done to protect the monitor from damage that may occur if a steady voltage is supplied. Instead positive voltage is used then negative in a cycle. The cycle uses an inversion pattern so that any visible effects are ditthered. This kind of inversion is most common and ideally will not be noticeable in daily use.
The second kind is typically more noticeable and more associated with modern 240hz monitors. It is the inversion pattern used for FRC. The monitor accpets an 8-bit signal but uses a 6-bit panel. To produce the last 2 bits of contrast the panel is alternated between ligher and darker shades over time. This alternation uses an inversion pattern to mask the puslsing. Fast eyes can catch it but more importantly it can be linked to refresh rate. So some situations particularly with gsync dropping to very low refreshes can make the inversion pattern very visible. Also the right kind of animations can show it. If something is already pulsing every other frame on part of the screen then it will catch half of the inversion pattern. There were some issues with earlier versions of windows 10 and earlier nvidia drivers that resulted in pulsing screens with inversion patterns in many games when the framerate dropped.
Im not sure if there are 8-bit 240hz panels in monitors yet. If there are maybe someone can chime in and that may be a good monitor for you to try.
But I can find no other source other than this
https://www.displayspecifications.com/en/model/aeb21048
They can't be just blatantly wrong because they label the XL2540 and XL2546 as both 6 bits+FRC.
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
Even if it is 8bit there can still be inversion patterns. However I tend to think that the issue is related to FRC given that some situations can exacerbate the FRC issue. And also the the mention that windowed mode and linux do not present as many problems.
That said it doesn't have to be FRC related.
I would try to get more than one website confirming the true 8-bit status. Sometimes you can look up the panel and see if it is 8-bit.
That said it doesn't have to be FRC related.
I would try to get more than one website confirming the true 8-bit status. Sometimes you can look up the panel and see if it is 8-bit.
-
- Posts: 2795
- Joined: 26 Mar 2014, 07:23
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
I can't find the panel name anywhere. I'm still stuck on a XL2720Z.open wrote:Even if it is 8bit there can still be inversion patterns. However I tend to think that the issue is related to FRC given that some situations can exacerbate the FRC issue. And also the the mention that windowed mode and linux do not present as many problems.
That said it doesn't have to be FRC related.
I would try to get more than one website confirming the true 8-bit status. Sometimes you can look up the panel and see if it is 8-bit.
Someone would have to take an XL2740 and go into the service menu and the factory menu (try both) and write down the AUO part number shown at the top.
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 16 Jun 2019, 14:33
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
mine (xl 2546) is 6 + FRC. My only doubt is if this model is normal, since of 3 equal monitors, all 3 have the same problem. I do not understand how they do not fix this anomaly, it is assumed that there are already advances in technology so as not to solve this in a more effective wayopen wrote:Even if it is 8bit there can still be inversion patterns. However I tend to think that the issue is related to FRC given that some situations can exacerbate the FRC issue. And also the the mention that windowed mode and linux do not present as many problems.
That said it doesn't have to be FRC related.
I would try to get more than one website confirming the true 8-bit status. Sometimes you can look up the panel and see if it is 8-bit.
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 16 Jun 2019, 14:33
Re: Pixel inversion artifacts, something normal in Zowie XL2
but if I'm not wrong, the matrix of xl2546 and that of the Dell alienware aw2518f are different, and in both for example there is pixel inversion. Even under my perception the pixel inversion of the Dell monitor is more accentuated than in the zowieFalkentyne wrote:I can't find the panel name anywhere. I'm still stuck on a XL2720Z.open wrote:Even if it is 8bit there can still be inversion patterns. However I tend to think that the issue is related to FRC given that some situations can exacerbate the FRC issue. And also the the mention that windowed mode and linux do not present as many problems.
That said it doesn't have to be FRC related.
I would try to get more than one website confirming the true 8-bit status. Sometimes you can look up the panel and see if it is 8-bit.
Someone would have to take an XL2740 and go into the service menu and the factory menu (try both) and write down the AUO part number shown at the top.