Data/Feedback required. Please test/try something for me
Posted: 06 Jun 2025, 11:30
Hello everyone,
as a few might have noticed, the old thread I created was closed a few weeks ago. That was a good decision as nothing productive came from it any more. Despite the topic being closed, I've not given up on testing and researching the problem some more.
This post focuses on the problems that are regularly brought up, like heavy input lag, desync and similar delays that shouldn't happen. I've gotten much more insight into my specific problem and I'm now able to reproduce a good feeling experience consistently, with very simple adjustments to my setup. I'm even able to "switch" between the PC behaving normally and horribly, and it shows up on the data I've collected with my monitor's integrated LDAT unit, which can measure the click-to-display delay. Don't worry though, you don't need to take LDAT measurements to deliver helpful information for me.
This testing methodology revolves around electricity, and despite me not giving any instructions that would have you come into contact with electricity, I'm still going to put the usual disclaimer: Don't open any devices, don't touch any wires and don't do stupid stuff. One single wrong step, your hand placed in the wrong spot once or your screwdriver accidentally slipping can instantly kill you. Don't poke around anything that could somewhat be considered dangerous if you don't know what you're doing.
Also, if you're of the opinion that electricity doesn't affect anything and all the problems come from Windows or anything else, this thread isn't for you and I'd like to ask you politely to skip it.
With that out of the way, everyone still reading can contribute to me understanding the problem better.
First, I want you to remove all electrical devices from the circuit your computer is plugged into. If you don't know which room is on which circuit, simply remove all devices that are plugged in across the entire room. Make sure that, at least in the room you're in, all the outlets are free and no devices are plugged into them. Remove your computer and all devices associated with it as well, so your room is completely "free" of electrical devices.
Secondly, I want you to connect a single power strip to an outlet. What kind of power strip doesn't really matter, however a "dumb" power strip without much filtering/other "smarts" is ideal.
Next, I want you to plug in your devices in a very specific order. Most power strips are a "daisy-chain" style internally. This means that all outlets on the power strip are connected in series. For this test you need to know which outlet on the power strip is wired "first". STOP! Do not open it up and do not look inside. There might be components inside that will kill you, even when the thing is unplugged. Cheap power strips will try to save on materials, so in 99% of cases, the outlet closest to the side where the cable comes in will be the "first" one. Go by this rule instead of looking!
Next, take a look at this image. As you can see, I've numbered the outlets (sw is for "Switch", don't worry if yours doesn't have one, it'll still be the same).
https://ibb.co/xrQWmf2
Plug your devices in like this:
1: Computer / Console
2: Main monitor
3: Router / Switch / Network equipment
4: Audio equipment like DAC/AMP
The most important part is to plug in the computer/console into the first outlet on the chain. If you usually use more monitors, leave them unplugged for the duration of the test. If you need for example a router and a switch, plug them in after each other and move anything downstream one spot further. Anything not necessary for the operation of the computer should be left unplugged for the duration of the test.
Please play with this configuration a bit and report back how it feels. Answer a few questions if possible:
1. Are you on a computer, a laptop or a console?
2. Did the feeling change at all?
3. Assuming it changed, does it feel better or worse?
4. Can you pinpoint what exactly feels better or worse?
5. If the feeling didn't change: Are you in a house or an apartment?
6. If the feeling changed to better: Unplug the computer from the 1st outlet and plug it into the last one. Does that worsen the feeling again?
7. If the feeling changed to worse: Unplug the computer from the 1st outlet and plug it into the last one. Does that improve the feeling?
EDIT: A few more questions which I initially didn't think of, but could be very helpful.
8. Which country / region are you from?
9. With "3-prong" plugs, does your plug/socket enforce polarity? Can you only insert the plug one way, or can you rotate it 180°? (Example: North America's NEMA 5-15 plugs enforce polarity, Germany's SCHUKO plugs don't)
I hope to get answers on these questions from a few readers. However, if you don't feel like answering all of them, a simple "it's better" or "it's the same" is also enough.
If this returns mostly positive results, I might go into more detail on what I think the problem is. For now, I want to see if this does or doesn't change the feeling of the computer for a larger number of people.
Thanks to anyone taking part and trying this out.
as a few might have noticed, the old thread I created was closed a few weeks ago. That was a good decision as nothing productive came from it any more. Despite the topic being closed, I've not given up on testing and researching the problem some more.
This post focuses on the problems that are regularly brought up, like heavy input lag, desync and similar delays that shouldn't happen. I've gotten much more insight into my specific problem and I'm now able to reproduce a good feeling experience consistently, with very simple adjustments to my setup. I'm even able to "switch" between the PC behaving normally and horribly, and it shows up on the data I've collected with my monitor's integrated LDAT unit, which can measure the click-to-display delay. Don't worry though, you don't need to take LDAT measurements to deliver helpful information for me.
This testing methodology revolves around electricity, and despite me not giving any instructions that would have you come into contact with electricity, I'm still going to put the usual disclaimer: Don't open any devices, don't touch any wires and don't do stupid stuff. One single wrong step, your hand placed in the wrong spot once or your screwdriver accidentally slipping can instantly kill you. Don't poke around anything that could somewhat be considered dangerous if you don't know what you're doing.
Also, if you're of the opinion that electricity doesn't affect anything and all the problems come from Windows or anything else, this thread isn't for you and I'd like to ask you politely to skip it.
With that out of the way, everyone still reading can contribute to me understanding the problem better.
First, I want you to remove all electrical devices from the circuit your computer is plugged into. If you don't know which room is on which circuit, simply remove all devices that are plugged in across the entire room. Make sure that, at least in the room you're in, all the outlets are free and no devices are plugged into them. Remove your computer and all devices associated with it as well, so your room is completely "free" of electrical devices.
Secondly, I want you to connect a single power strip to an outlet. What kind of power strip doesn't really matter, however a "dumb" power strip without much filtering/other "smarts" is ideal.
Next, I want you to plug in your devices in a very specific order. Most power strips are a "daisy-chain" style internally. This means that all outlets on the power strip are connected in series. For this test you need to know which outlet on the power strip is wired "first". STOP! Do not open it up and do not look inside. There might be components inside that will kill you, even when the thing is unplugged. Cheap power strips will try to save on materials, so in 99% of cases, the outlet closest to the side where the cable comes in will be the "first" one. Go by this rule instead of looking!
Next, take a look at this image. As you can see, I've numbered the outlets (sw is for "Switch", don't worry if yours doesn't have one, it'll still be the same).
https://ibb.co/xrQWmf2
Plug your devices in like this:
1: Computer / Console
2: Main monitor
3: Router / Switch / Network equipment
4: Audio equipment like DAC/AMP
The most important part is to plug in the computer/console into the first outlet on the chain. If you usually use more monitors, leave them unplugged for the duration of the test. If you need for example a router and a switch, plug them in after each other and move anything downstream one spot further. Anything not necessary for the operation of the computer should be left unplugged for the duration of the test.
Please play with this configuration a bit and report back how it feels. Answer a few questions if possible:
1. Are you on a computer, a laptop or a console?
2. Did the feeling change at all?
3. Assuming it changed, does it feel better or worse?
4. Can you pinpoint what exactly feels better or worse?
5. If the feeling didn't change: Are you in a house or an apartment?
6. If the feeling changed to better: Unplug the computer from the 1st outlet and plug it into the last one. Does that worsen the feeling again?
7. If the feeling changed to worse: Unplug the computer from the 1st outlet and plug it into the last one. Does that improve the feeling?
EDIT: A few more questions which I initially didn't think of, but could be very helpful.
8. Which country / region are you from?
9. With "3-prong" plugs, does your plug/socket enforce polarity? Can you only insert the plug one way, or can you rotate it 180°? (Example: North America's NEMA 5-15 plugs enforce polarity, Germany's SCHUKO plugs don't)
I hope to get answers on these questions from a few readers. However, if you don't feel like answering all of them, a simple "it's better" or "it's the same" is also enough.
If this returns mostly positive results, I might go into more detail on what I think the problem is. For now, I want to see if this does or doesn't change the feeling of the computer for a larger number of people.
Thanks to anyone taking part and trying this out.