Trying to understand what causes eyestrain for me.

There are over 100 ergonomic issues from displays, far more than just flicker and blue light. This forum covers the giant variety of display ergonomics issues.
Post Reply
oblivio69
Posts: 3
Joined: 07 Jul 2020, 18:12

Trying to understand what causes eyestrain for me.

Post by oblivio69 » Yesterday, 04:56

Hey guys, I got a new monitor (AOC AGON Pro CS24A 600Hz TN) and it's causing pretty bad eye strain, and I'm not sure what I should try before returning it.

My history regarding monitors:

Comfortable:
- BenQ Zowie XL2730 (144Hz 1440p TN) - my first high-Hz monitor, absolutely perfect if I remember correctly.
- BenQ Zowie XL2546K (240Hz TN) - perfectly comfortable too, used DyAc most of the time.
- BenQ Zowie XL2566X+ (400Hz TN) - bought this autumn, used it for about two months at 100% brightness with no eye strain. DyAc 2 does feel a tiny bit more tiring than having it off, but totally bearable for a few hours of gaming. Returned it to try the 600Hz CS24A.
- Alienware AW2720HF (27" 1080p 240Hz IPS, standard sRGB) - used as a secondary. Found it a bit dim and not quite at Zowie's level, maybe 85–90% as comfortable (a bit above the WOLED, still under the Zowie TNs), though fine overall.
- Apple screens (M4 Max MacBook Pro + Apple Studio Display) - I run both at max SDR brightness for work and don't really get this kind of eye fatigue.

Uncomfortable:
- Alienware AW2721D (27" 1440p 240Hz Nano IPS) - straining and tiring on the eyes, though still doable.
- Samsung 360Hz QD-OLED (27") - tested last year, very bad for my eyes. Felt way too dim for my liking, yet the colors looked "radioactive" / overly glowy. Returned it.
- ASUS 27" 480Hz WOLED - tested right after the Samsung. Pretty sure I had sRGB mode turned on, and eye-strain wise it was decent (still not quite as effortless as a BenQ or the AW2720HF, though I didn't use it for work so not much text reading). Returned it as well.
- AOC CS24A (600Hz TN) - got it yesterday and it completely wrecked my eyes with a persistent stinging / burning feeling.

A few extra details:
- I have astigmatism and hyperopia (farsightedness), not sure how much that factors in.
- On all the uncomfortable monitors, reds looked overly saturated (like the red YouTube logo in Chrome looking neon). On the CS24A in CS2, colors felt way more intense and sunlit areas on Mirage looked disturbingly bright.
- One weird thing on the CS24A: MBR+ acts like a secondary brightness boost — MBR 0 (off) is lower brightness, MBR 10 jumps noticeably higher, then it decreases again going toward 20.
- The CS24A OSD doesn't allow its built-in sRGB mode while MBR+ is enabled. I tried AMD's driver sRGB clamp (Custom Color on, Color Temp Control off) with MBR+/HDR/DCR off, and it made colors look dull while my eyes still stung (though my eyes were already irritated from the first session).

My current theories / assumptions:
1. Unmanaged wide color gamut on Windows: Every comfortable PC monitor I've owned is native sRGB (the Zowies and the AW2720HF), while my Apple displays are color-managed by macOS. Every uncomfortable PC monitor (AW2721D, QD-OLED, WOLED, CS24A) is wide gamut (~94%+ DCI-P3).
2. Backlight spectrum / KSF (PFS) red phosphor? I always suspected KSF on the AW2721D, and I'm wondering if the CS24A uses a KSF backlight too (couldn't find any published spectrum for it). Though if the Studio Display uses KSF and doesn't bother me, maybe KSF alone isn't it.
3. Aggressive MBR+ brightness/overdrive + high gamma/glare: Since DyAc already gives me slight fatigue, maybe the CS24A pushing higher peak brightness at MBR+ 10 (plus bright CS2 presets) pushed me way past my threshold.
4. Unit-specific issue like 600Hz pixel inversion flicker (planning to run Lagom and a slow-mo phone test on fresh eyes).

Has anyone else experienced this on the CS24A / AG246FK6, or knows what backlight/panel behavior it has? Before I return it, what settings or tests would you recommend trying (e.g., higher MBR+ 16-20 with lower brightness, or dialing back R.Saturation in the OSD)? And if I do return it, is there any 480Hz+ option that won't trigger this, or am I basically stuck going back to the XL2566X+?

---

TL;DR:
Got the AOC CS24A (600Hz TN) and it's giving me severe eye strain / burning.
- Good for my eyes: BenQ Zowie XL2730, XL2546K, XL2566X+ (best overall), M4 Max MacBook Pro & Apple Studio Display (max SDR brightness), Alienware AW2720HF (~85-90% comfort).
- Bad for my eyes: AOC CS24A (worst), Samsung 360Hz QD-OLED (nearly as bad, dim yet radioactive colors), Alienware AW2721D (tiring but doable), ASUS 480Hz WOLED (decent in sRGB, still below Zowie/AW2720HF).
- Main suspects: Unmanaged wide gamut on Windows (every comfortable Windows monitor was native sRGB), KSF backlight, and/or aggressive MBR+ brightness spikes. Looking for settings/tests to try before returning, or a 480Hz+ alternative that won't hurt my eyes.
- I mainly play competitive FPS when I game thus the crappy color TN is ok.

User avatar
kyube
Posts: 1045
Joined: 29 Jan 2018, 12:03

Re: Trying to understand what causes eyestrain for me.

Post by kyube » Today, 01:25

oblivio69 wrote: ↑
Yesterday, 04:56
--snip--
The AG246FK6 & CS24A both employ a KSF WLED backlight, as per this test data @ 02:30
As for narrow color gamut options, you're correct for the FHD segment.
The XL2566X+ & XL2566K are the last two YAG phosphor WLED backlight models.
In the QHD segment, the Pulsar panels (e.g.: XG27AQNGV) are a rare exception with a YAG phosphor WLED backlight.
Other than these two, in the ≥300Hz refresh rate segment, everything else is either QD or KSF.

MBR+ & DyAc2 have the same principle of functioning – discrete rolling scan strobing with their 10 segment backlight.
However, DyAc1 & DyAc2 have stronger voltage boosting behavior.
I'd argue that this part of MBR+ isn't what your issue is rooted in, but I can't claim absolutes.

oblivio69
Posts: 3
Joined: 07 Jul 2020, 18:12

Re: Trying to understand what causes eyestrain for me.

Post by oblivio69 » Today, 05:39

So your hunch is that the KSF WLED backlight is the main issue ?

Tbh I'm at a loss, I personally wouldn't go for the pulsar since I have a 9070xt and additionally I want to have at least 480hz. (I did feel a difference between 400 and 600hz).
Going to read a bit about glasses, I haven't changed mine in a couple of years and I wonder if there are new coatings that would help with eye strain on the glasses side.

Yesterday, after using a color clamp from AMD, and lowering the brightness a bit on the cs24a, it was much better but still far from ideal, the one thing I keep noticing is that some of the reds are quite deep, and sort of shimmering if I look at them.

I'm quite tempted to try another woled, the lg 540hz one has good prices in my country but it's quite sad they went with a matte coating.

User avatar
kyube
Posts: 1045
Joined: 29 Jan 2018, 12:03

Re: Trying to understand what causes eyestrain for me.

Post by kyube » Today, 10:26

oblivio69 wrote: ↑
Today, 05:39
So your hunch is that the KSF WLED backlight is the main issue ?
I have no hunch. It's a possibility. Exact % of likelihood is unknown.
It might be a completely different mechanism at play here.
It might be a health-related concern (health defficiency or genetic factor or something else entirely) which prevents a certain crowd unable to deal with specific monitor panels.
The fact you're using 100% brightness doesn't help the situation either.
oblivio69 wrote: ↑
Today, 05:39
Going to read a bit about glasses, I haven't changed mine in a couple of years and I wonder if there are new coatings that would help with eye strain on the glasses side.
AFAIK, there's no coating on clear lenses which alter the red segment of KSF monitors.
The glasses would have to be slightly blue/green-tinted if you want to filter out the KSF peak.
There's also display-level color gamut clamping, which Asus offers on their displays, through the “Display Color Space” setting.
See manual

I did notice that the AG246FK6 offers a Color Gamut setting in it's OSD menu, as per this manual

In comparison, the MSI 242R X60N & XL2586X (the only 540–600Hz QD) don't offer a distinct setting.

Post Reply