VRR STROBING Monitors List

Ask about motion blur reduction in gaming monitors. Includes ULMB (Ultra Low Motion Blur), NVIDIA LightBoost, ASUS ELMB, BenQ/Zowie DyAc, ToastyX, black frame insertion (BFI), and now framerate-based motion blur reduction (framegen / LSS / etc).
User avatar
Discorz
VIP Member
Posts: 1157
Joined: 06 Sep 2019, 02:39
Location: Europe, Croatia
Contact:

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by Discorz » 09 May 2022, 04:27

Good news! RTINGS now seems to do proper-ish vrr strobing motion photos for updated v1.2 test bench. They have their own executable "game" for pursuit photos where they can control vrr frame rate, similar to AG Smooth Frog.

Test Bench 1.2 Changelog
RTINGS wrote:
  • Added more motion blur pictures to show the backlight strobing performance across different refresh rates and modes.
  • Monitor's refresh rate and the "in-game" frame rate are set to the same frequency, but we now test with VRR enabled.
Meaning:
- VRR enabled
- monitor set to max refresh rate
- vrr framerate set to 'max', 120 or other fps

BUT in some cases their camera tracking accuracy is still off and they use anti-aliased edge image patterns. So if they captured fastest persistence displays like CRT photo would still look blurry. Meaning given motion photo would never be an accurate demonstration of display's persistence. They also use differently sized patterns for different pixel density. That is something to have in mind. I e-mailed them and pointed this out as well as suggested some other changes regarding motion photos.

Here are some examples:

M32Q Backlight Strobing + VRR, 93 ppi
RTINGS 120 FPS
Image
RE-TEST 120 FPS
Image

VG279QM, Backlight Strobing + VRR, 81 ppi
RTINGS 120 FPS
Image
RE-TEST 120 FPS
Image

∼960 pps

Ezzelin
Posts: 1
Joined: 06 Jan 2023, 18:57

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by Ezzelin » 06 Jan 2023, 19:03

Hello! I recently bought a Asus XG32UQ and can confirm that it can activate ELMB Sync at 160Hz. It also sadly has a KSF phosphor, so I might be returning it, although it's not as disruptive as I imagined it being when I'm not looking at pursuit patterns or dragging a window.

liquidshadowfox
Posts: 290
Joined: 05 Nov 2020, 14:03

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by liquidshadowfox » 26 Apr 2023, 07:56

Apparently the BenQ MOBIUZ EX270QM supports VRR + backlight strobing according to 1 reviewer above 100 fps. I don't know how this one flew under the radar...

konchy
Posts: 14
Joined: 11 Dec 2018, 04:54

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by konchy » 30 Apr 2023, 02:42

liquidshadowfox wrote: ↑
26 Apr 2023, 07:56
Apparently the BenQ MOBIUZ EX270QM supports VRR + backlight strobing according to 1 reviewer above 100 fps. I don't know how this one flew under the radar...
The benq ex240 too according to a YouTube reviewer

liquidshadowfox
Posts: 290
Joined: 05 Nov 2020, 14:03

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by liquidshadowfox » 30 Apr 2023, 13:16

Wow this BenQ MOBIUZ EX270QM monitor is not bad! the VRR + strobing performance is similar to the gigabyte m27q X (yes red phosphor is present) with some extra features. For one, you can actually increase the brightness in strobe and it gets pretty bright! Strobe works above 80 hz and the best OD for each refresh are
ama 0 = fps < 85
ama 1 = 86 - 140
ama 2 = 141 - 240
ama 3 = gives more speed for 240 but I notice the overshoot.
I tested this by enabling the Gsync compatible flag in nvidia control panel, using hdmi 2.1 and using smooth frog to test the VRR range + strobe. Low motion blur clarity is best in the middle, then bottom and then the worst crosstalk is at the top of the screen. Going to be testing this monitor out for the next week or so.

Edit: Really annoying bug, when you have games in exclusive fullscreen the screen blacks out for 2 - 3 seconds between alt tabbing AND the game set's the monitor to downscaled 4k @ 120 hz setting every time. I had to use CRU to delete the virtual 4k setting (probably there for ps4 compatibility with consoles) and the issue of 2 - 3 seconds of black out STILL occurs (doesn't happen if you are in borderless windowed). It doesn't occur if the refresh of the monitor is set to 200 hz vs using 240 hz so I assume something is wrong with the DSC implementation on this monitor.

liquidshadowfox
Posts: 290
Joined: 05 Nov 2020, 14:03

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by liquidshadowfox » 26 May 2023, 13:06

According to someone's review on newegg talking about the Asus XG27AQMR, it's better than the XG27AQM apparently given he's tried out a bunch of monitors and it does support elmb sync. Not sure if anyone here has this monitor and reported it's performance but given it has 300 hz and more brightness than the XG27AQM, it might have some marginal improvements. Also the fact they say it has a 1 ms response time vs the 0.5 of the XG27AQM is because they toned back the overdrive so there's no inverse ghosting even at the highest overdrive level (at max refresh) according to one asian reviewer online.

User avatar
kyube
Posts: 1048
Joined: 29 Jan 2018, 12:03

Re: VRR STROBING Monitors List

Post by kyube » Today, 06:53

Discorz wrote: ↑
09 Jul 2021, 03:27
--snip--
I want to update this list with a few new implementations & models.
Manifacturers:
- Titan Army: DYDS 2.0 Sync
- MSI: SLMB-Sync (likely MSI's discrete rolling scan implementation)
- TCL: MPRT-Plus

Models (I'll only list a few):
• ASUS XG27AQNGV / MSI 272QRF X36 / ACER XB273U F5 / AOC AG276QSG2 (G-SYNC Pulsar)

• AOC AG246FK6 / CS24A (FHD600Hz; MBR-SYNC)

• MSI MSI MAG 271KPD7 (5k75Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 322URD16 (4K144Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 321UPD E14 (4K144Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 256QP36 (QHD360Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 346CQDF E20 (QHD360Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 274CQPDF X32 (QHD320Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 276QE34 (QHD340Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 325CQPD27 (QHD275Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MAG MAG 275QED27 (QHD275Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MAG 276QR42 (QHD425Hz; SLMB-SYNC)
• MSI MPG 242R X60N (FHD600Hz; MPRT-SYNC)

• Titan Army P245MS Pro+ (QHD420Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army P245MS Pro (QHD380Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army P245MS (QHD240Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army U275T (QHD425Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army X276T (QHD425Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army P275MS PLUS+ (QHD; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army P275MS PRO (QHD345Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army KG277S PLUS (QHD275Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army P276MX Ultra (5K180Hz; DYDS 2.0)
• Titan Army U275M (QHD565Hz; DYDS 2.0)

• TCL 25P2A PRO (QHD360Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL 27P2A (QHD200Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL 27P2A PRO (QHD320Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL 27C2A (4K160Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL 25P1A (FHD300Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL 34C2A (WQHD200Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL P3A Pro (QHD320Hz; MPRT-PLUS)
• TCL P3A (QHD260Hz; MPRT-PLUS)

• ASUS ROG Strix XG27ACMESR (QHD280Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27ACNS (QHD475Hz; HD920Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27UCGR-G (4k162Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27ACMSR (QHD360Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG259QNSR Ace (FHD420Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27UCMG (4K240Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27JCEG (5K80Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ASUS ROG Strix XG27JCG (5K180Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
• ROG Strix XG248QSG Ace (FHD610Hz; ELMB-SYNC)
One can find other models here
For the TUF lineup, here

To get slightly off-topic, we also have the rabbit hole of models mentioned as having the feature not implementing it at all.
From small testing I've had a user do, the Q25G4SR (the hidden 320Hz re-release) seemingly doesn't have working MBR-SYNC.
I don't know if this holds up for the 300Hz variant.
The test was simple:
- Get a slowmo-capable phone camera
- Run the typical VRR+VSYNC+Reflex autocap setup
- See if the screen flickers
With much tinkering, we weren't able to invoke any kind of flickering.

The most important question one has to ask for all of this is– what MPRT x Refresh rate curve does each implementation have?
As it stands, we have this official data to go by:
G-SYNC Pulsar – 20% @ 100Hz; ~22,5–24,6% @ 150Hz; ~26,14% @ 200Hz; 31,41% @ 250Hz; ~33,84% @ 300Hz;

As for ASUS' ELMB-SYNC on their TUF monitors (e.g.: VG279QM), it likely follows this curve, as showcased by Ashun from ApertureGrille (now working at RTINGS):
~81,6% @ 120Hz; ~59,524% @ 240Hz;
This implementation likely doesn't hold up for all models that ASUS makes and is likely model-dependant...

As for TCL's MPRT-PLUS, we only have this review to go by
This review mentions a ~30% @ 320Hz point @ 490 cd/m²

As for Titan Army's DYDS 2.0 Sync feature:
41,8% @ 315 cd/m²; unknown refresh rate, likely maximum 345Hz


As it stands, Pulsar has seemingly the best confirmed curve on the market. Though, we have yet to explore the numerious other implementations in proper depth.
TCL's MPRT-PLUS might have potential, considering that it targets around a similar duty cycle at it's maximum refresh rate.
In my opinion, a "ideal" clarity-first curve, given the limitations, would have the following properties
We need more users to be doing proper testing, such as outlined by Discorz in here
Here's my explanation for it

Post Reply